Since I chanced upon the Tweets and Facebook updates a few days ago of Beena Sarwar, a leading journalist, artist and filmmaker in Pakistan, I have been feasting on a rich repast of articles, blogs and commentaries that show how vast is the constituency of Pakistani people who harbour cordial feelings towards Indians, how many of them desire nothing but peace and mutual well-being and how generously they acknowledge the positive sentiments Indian visitors to their country express.

I am deeply grateful for this. Because, for many years, whenever I’ve come across the words “failed state” and Pakistan in the same sentence, I’ve fidgeted, thinking that surely one simply cannot equate a people – and so many warm-hearted people – with as amorphous a concept as “state” and throwing out, if I may use an ancient cliché, the baby with the bathwater.

And warm-hearted the people of Pakistan most reputedly are. Countless have been the accounts I’ve read over the past many decades, by Indian journalists, academics, civil society activists, film-makers as well as people in the official establishment, of immense generosity that was showered upon them in the Pakistani street as well as in air-conditioned altars of the genteel bourgeoisie. Almost all have spoken of being treated courteously, restaurateurs refusing payment for tea, snacks or meals on learning the diner was from the other side of the border, and countless similar gracious gestures.

Professor Jagannath Azad was asked by Mohammad Ali Jinnah, the Founding Father of Pakistan, to compose the national anthem. It was approved but subsequently abandoned. some activists want to resurrect it. (Photo from http://www.jagannathazad.info/)

We live in an era of complex loyalties. Many men throughout the world have fanatical attachment to some football teams in corners of England or continental Europe. Almost everyone sides with teams from their own “country” or “nation”, often without questioning how old – or strongly identified with – that country is or nationhood is.

I remember a day in late 1985 when I sat in the press gallery between S. Nihal Singh, the renowned former editor of The Statesman, and a UNESCO official, a Pakistani (whose name escapes me), during that organisation’s General Conference in Sofia, Bulgaria. The two spoke to each other in Punjabi for a while. The Pakistani gentleman asked me whether I’d caught anything of what they’d been saying. A few words are similar to Hindi (the North Indian language imposed on us South Indians in schools), I mumbled. It occurred to me that I had less in common with the person of the same “nationality” as mine than the two of them had with each other.

I’m also reminded of the time in the late 1990s when I “discovered” Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. I was almost exclusively into Western Classical those days but the CD shop in Hong Kong I was in had prominently displayed Khan Sahib’s 1995 collaborative album with Michael Brook, Night Song (http://michaelbrookmusic.com/night-song). Listening to it, I was covered with goose bumps and washed over by a sense of pride. Pride in what, I asked myself. In the immense talent and global fame of a fellow South Asian.

These were moments of epiphany, although I was only too acutely aware of the many ironies and tragedies of Partition.

Now that technology allows us to transcend borders and connect instantaneously, it is imperative that as many of us as possible join hands to celebrate our common humanity.

Which brings me back to Beena Sarwar’s newsfeeds. Following is a sample of the kind of articles she has been flagging:

One of the most amazing is her own blog entry about Pakistan’s first anthem. Founding father Mohammad Ali Jinnah had asked Poet Jagannath Azad to write it.  http://beenasarwar.wordpress.com/2010/04/09/jagan-nath-azads-pakistan-tarana/

How fascinating it is that that a man who eventually – and reluctantly – moved to India after Partition had written the first anthem of Pakistan, that a song Indian schoolchildren grow up with, Saare Jahan se Achha, was composed by Muhammad Iqbal, who is regarded as the national poet of Pakistan, and that Rabindranath Tagore is the author of the national anthems of both India and Bangladesh.

Beena Sarwar has mounted a campaign to resurrect Azad’s anthem. “Bring back Jagannath Azad’s Pakistan anthem” http://beenasarwar.wordpress.com/2009/09/19/bring-back-jagannath-azads-anthem/

Her latest on the issue is here: “65 years… Reviving Jagannath Azad’s poem for Pakistan” http://beenasarwar.wordpress.com/2012/08/14/65-years-later-reviving-jagannath-azads-poem-pakistan/

The following is, of course, an appeal by a Pakistani to his compatriots: “Jinnah’s Pakistan cannot be abandoned” by Raza Rumi http://www.jinnah-institute.org/issues/secular-space/525-jinnahs-pakistan-cannot-be-abandoned

A nice article from 2010 on Gandhi was tweeted by her a few days ago: “Gandhi and Islam: Syed Ashraf Ali reviews the great man’s admiration for the religion of peace” http://www.thedailystar.net/forum/2010/august/gandhi.htm

She has flagged reports about minorities in Pakistan. “In solidarity: ‘There are conspiracies to make Hindus leave Pakistan’” http://tribune.com.pk/story/414722/in-solidarity-there-are-conspiracies-to-make-hindus-leave-pakistan/#.UCf5p1WPCnw.facebook

And related to that, “Lawyer leaves for Jacobabad to promote interfaith harmony” http://www.thenews.com.pk/Todays-News-7-126128-Lawyer-leaves-for-Jacobabad-to-promote-interfaith-harmony

Sarwar has also flagged reports of Indians or those of Indian origin visiting Pakistan and being awestruck. “Eye Opener: An Indian-American Visits Pakistan” http://usindiamonitor.com/2012/07/08/eye-opener-an-indian-american-visits-pakistan/

Blogger Riaz Haq has compiled a few impressions of visitors from the other side in “Indians Share ‘Eye-Opener’ Stories of Pakistan” http://www.riazhaq.com/2012/07/indians-share-eye-opening-stories-of.html

The following too might have come via Sarwar: “Going from love to love across the border” http://dawn.com/2012/08/13/going-from-love-to-love-across-the-border/

I end with my fellow Bangalorean Prakash Belawadi’s plea for an annual Independence Day Friendship Concert at Wagah, which, he says, “would make the ultimate jugalbandi of our shared musical heritage”. http://tribune.com.pk/story/419729/we-must-at-wagah/#comment-858316

When that jugalbandi happens, I want one of my favourite ensembles, Sachal Studio, to be there: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLF46JKkCNg. And I hope to go and watch them with a can of Murree in hand: http://www.tehelka.com/story_main53.asp?filename=Ne180812Door.asp.

Jiye Pakistan, Long Live Pakistan, Pakistan Zindabad !

About walkerjay

The author, N. Jayaram, a journalist now based in Bangalore after more than 23 years in East Asia (mainly Hong Kong and Beijing) and 11 years in New Delhi, was with the Press Trust of India news agency for 15 years and Agence France-Presse for 11 years and is currently engaged in editing and translating for NGOs and academic institutions.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.


  1. I discovered her Facebook page a few days back too and am following her now.

  2. another collaborative.. Petition for Recognition & Adoption of Hindi-Urdu as the 7th Official UN Language


  3. Aniery says:

    When one realises the money spent by both countries on their respective armies, one wishes Partition never happened. Gandhi was right.
    The money and energy spent on keeping Kashmir in India is mindboggling! That was the end of secular India.
    Nehru and his cronies ruined the chance of peace and equal development (education, health, housing,…) for South Asia and it’s citizens! Of course, Jinnah also played well the same game!

  4. shovonc says:

    Your story reminds me of Kapil Dev getting hit for a six by Wasim Akram, after which the two of them exchanged some choice Punjabi galis. Behind the stumps, Sadanand Vishwanath looked extremely perplexed!

  5. walkerjay says:

    Shovon, in March 2011 I wrote a tongue-in-cheek piece on cricket. One blessed Indian seriously wished me dead.

  6. Such a beautiful article on my dear homeland is need of the hour. Our populace (both in India and Pakistan) has so much been brainwashed that both consider the other as the ‘enemy’. On my blog I receive so many comments denouncing Pakistan, Islam and the Muslims that I think most Indians are anti Pakistani. BUT believe me Jiyaram Ji, as you rightly say there are a majority of poeple on both sides of the border who claimour for permanent peace in the subcontinent.
    These walls of animosity will vanish in a nu once there are people to people contacts. In this respect a person like you can play a big role. The words and feelings you have expressed in your article are the voice of a true Indian. Neither a patriot of Pakistan hates India nor the Indian patriots can hate Pakistan. Unfortunately politicians mainly equate patriotism with hatred to other people, other states much to serve their own petty interests.

    Its all the politicians in India and Pakistan, the media and the movie industry (which has an edge over the Pakistan film industry and therefore has better efficacy and power to impact the masses) that spit out hatred. As I said once the people to people contacts are established the impact of the movies, of the media as well as of the politicians will become so minimal that no one would care a damn for them.

    Nayyar Hashmey

  7. walkerjay says:

    Many thanks, Dr Hashmey! It is in the minds of humans that the defences of peace must be constructed. We shall do so, Doctor. We shall overcome!

  8. Pingback: Celebrating with the People of Pakistan « Wonders of Pakistan

  9. Pingback: On seeing the film garm hava for the third time « Wonders of Pakistan

  10. Pingback: Celebrating with the People of Pakistan

  11. Pingback: On seeing the film garm hava for the third time

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s